I'm kinda just below a 4 for this rating. I did enjoy it, I really liked the characters of Evan and Matt. I enjoyed their relationship, it's highs and lows - how difficult it was for these two to admit to friends that they were in a relationship. I liked Evan's family and how they took to Matt. I really liked the fact that it wasn't that big a deal for the children when Evan admitted to them that his relationship with Matt was more than just friends (and yes I speak from experience, the four of us genuinely did not care).
So why just below a 4? Mainly because there are other books that have set my pulse racing just that little bit more. That's not to say I don't recommend it, I do, it's a thoroughly enjoyable read.